View Single Post
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 17-12-2007, 12:47 AM
Gurdit's Avatar
Gurdit Gurdit is offline
— c o l d · m f —
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: India
Posts: 1,416
Total Points: 148,843.89
Gurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary memberGurdit is an Honorary member
Send a message via MSN to Gurdit Send a message via Yahoo to Gurdit
Re: To Be, That is the Question

Quote:
You can learn much, watching people when they think they’re alone.
How about replacing the comma with a "by"?


Quote:
his Mother’s cooking
Just out of curiosity, any reason Mother is capitalized?


Quote:
He thinks that even though it’s a war zone, that the desert is actually a beautiful place.
The second that is a grammatical error.


Quote:
You can learn much, watching people when they think they’re alone.
Yet again, comma vs "by"


Now the piece itself:
I like the idea of it. Very very nicely written. The only thing that confused me a bit was why the sniper seems to have a telepathic connection with the man he's about to kill. With the refrains of "I am as God made me" changing into "I am not as God made me", I feel like the main character is the sniper. Yet, you write in such a way that I feel like I'm empathizing with the victim, with sentences like "Just then, he smiles; he figures it all out. The World, the War, his very existence."

This sentence I felt was your most powerful sentence, and it's dedicated to the victim. So now I'm really confused as to who the "hero" of this otherwise wonderfully written piece is.
__________________
If you don't let me know that you've read my comment, I will probably stop commenting on your writing.

Smile, and have a good day.
Reply With Quote