View Single Post
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 28-02-2008, 12:10 AM
Razor's Avatar
Razor Razor is offline
Story Reader & Weaver
Photobucket
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Kansas, US of A
Posts: 479
Total Points: 13,255.34
Razor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary memberRazor is an Honorary member
Re: The Sweetest Lullaby

Let me start with: Good job, I liked the story.

Let me continue with: This is solid throughout, there are some ways to strengthen it

You really shined when the dialog entered the story, and everything picked up. On the other hand, the beginning was a little slow as you developed the story. I'm not sure, off hand, how to improve that. I say this only because some readers decide in the first a paragraph or two whether they will continue reading, and it'd be shame for them to miss out on the rest.

Some little things could be tightened up, here is an example:

Quote:
My hands fumbled as they prepared the coffee maker. Soon, a warm aroma filled the room
It doesn't have the strength of writing the rest of this piece had. "My hands fumbled with the coffee maker until a warm aroma filled the room." Says the same thing and is a stronger read.

I realize sometimes you want to portray certain things with the extra words and that's what a good writer does, but there is a balance, that they must be used in moderation or it disrupts the story.


Quote:
I swiveled on the ball of my foot to make my way to the living room, but stalled
This sentence doesn't describe whats going on very well, at a time when the reader is anxious to know exactly how everything is playing out. Do you mean she actually swiveled...or that she started to... or was going to, but stalled because of the sound she heard. If Liam is coming from the living room, make it apparent that he is behind her as she pours the coffee. "I start to turn back into the living room, but...," or "My intention to go back into the living room is forgotten has I hear the slightest shift in the beige ..." whatever. You get the point.

One other thing...I didn't know it was a female Vampire....until late in the story. I mean the first indication of any kind is the name. I mean there was the interaction between Liam and the main character...but I try not to assume anything, because hey writers can write however he/she wants. Putting in a few descriptives of the character at the beginning, like the shower scene, work in the water flowing over her lithe hourglass frame, or something like that would be help me anyways.

Like I said, I enjoyed this. The writing is good, and it kept me reading despite being in a Vampire/Werewolf setting which has been written time and time again.

Good job, keep it up.
__________________
"All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players: they have their exits and their entrances; and one man in his time plays many parts, his acts being seven ages.." - William Shakespeare

Last edited by Razor; 28-02-2008 at 12:11 AM.
Reply With Quote