View Single Post
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 07-10-2007, 03:27 PM
Bluejay's Avatar
Bluejay Bluejay is offline
Dances with Words
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: San Leandro, California
Posts: 1,901
Total Points: 1,217,026.30
Bluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary memberBluejay is an Honorary member
Send a message via AIM to Bluejay Send a message via MSN to Bluejay Send a message via Yahoo to Bluejay
Re: Ducati Recollect

Overall, I was impressed with the narrative voice in this. From a vocabulary and sentence structure point of view (and even from a topic one), I wouldn't consider this an "amateur" piece. The only problem I had with it is that it felt incomplete, like it was a piece of a larger story instead of something complete in and of itself.

Part of that is the characters. While I enjoyed the depth of characterization of the main character, I never felt enough of a connection to care. Also, the conflict felt disconnected as well - suddenly it showed up in a car after halfway through. I appreciated what was happening, but I wanted more.

I thought the descriptions were quite good, and the words flowed mostly smoothly. The use of numbers in relation to the motorcycle seemed a bit much. Mixing "kilos" and "miles per hour" in the same sentence threw me for a moment. And then having 999 ccs and 139 horsepower felt like another unit switch. Minor, but I did notice.

Some additional word things:

Quote:
“You know what I miss most about David?” she asked lightheartedly as if she...
I would use that word instead.

Quote:
Unlike the evening gown debutantes and courtesans she had sought for her well endowed son
To me, this meant something other than what I think you intended.

Those are minor. Again, overall, I was quite impressed! I'll have to read more of your pieces. And I would like to see more to this one, too. I think more depth to the characters and their interactions could make this even more enjoyable.
__________________
"We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams." ~ Arthur William Edgar O'Shaughnessy

"Be bold and mighty forces will come to your aid." ~ Basil King
Reply With Quote