| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools |
Rating:
|
Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
This is way better than Journal of a 27 year old Flight Attendant. The premise was interesting. Stranded on an island, cannibals and the surprise ending. I thought it was very creative--though I think I read this in an Archie comic or something. Weird. The cannibal descriptions were wickedly awesome.
But, when she met the boy, I thought it was just a bit too convenient and coincidental. And to stay in one spot for twenty seven days, without exploring, doesn't cut it. I think she should have explored just a bit, like on the other side of the island and she decides to go the other end where the cannibals are in. The story was well written, though I thought some sentences needed better wording. Nonetheless, it was an awesome read. Hmmmmmmmmm...
__________________
![]() Slow bleak awakening from the morning dream, Brings me in contact with this sudden day, I am alive—this I. |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
well im glad you like it! yeah, i probably should have made her explore a little more in the 27 days, but i had the whole cannibal idea and wanted to get to it right away! and i've never read any archie comics so i don't know if its the same as one or something, anyway thanks for reading!
__________________
Give me love, give me peace on earth, give me light, give me life, keep me free from birth, give me hope, help me cope, with this heavy load, trying to, touch and reach you with, heart and soul. --George Harrison |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
Wow, that was a curve ball. The scene where Sharon is being "roasted" was very believable but throwing in the curve ball ending kind of just took away from the story in my opinion. Don't get discouraged by that though, I was wanting something else to happen entirely. As Peppy had said already some of the details were a bit odd. Such as the fact that she never explored while looking for food or water.
Last edited by timtornado3721; 30-08-2008 at 02:02 AM. |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
lol and what were you expecting tim? and trust me, i had tons of other endings. and yes, she did look for food, but stayed on that beach most of the time in case the ship came back...she just didnt totally explore the island because she was worried she'd miss a rescue boat, okay?
__________________
Give me love, give me peace on earth, give me light, give me life, keep me free from birth, give me hope, help me cope, with this heavy load, trying to, touch and reach you with, heart and soul. --George Harrison |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
I don't know, maybe some daring escape like in Pirates of the Caribbean 2 where she's running with Tommy toward a boat or possibly Tommy's Dad's boat or something. Yeah, saying that she explored a little helped explain that part of the story. Maybe you could add that in the first or second paragraph?
|
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
lol yeah i should add the exploring bit for sure.
btw Pirates was awesome lol
__________________
Give me love, give me peace on earth, give me light, give me life, keep me free from birth, give me hope, help me cope, with this heavy load, trying to, touch and reach you with, heart and soul. --George Harrison |
|
|||
|
Re: Trapped
Not really outstanding but the idea was fun. It could have been perhaps done a bit better with more meat around it but this was also a good read. I'm personally in for different kinds of stories but this one was excellent also despite the different type. The worst thing was that there was no link to the main character so that she seemed (to me at least) to remain a bit distant. It was imaginative though, so high points for that.
The best thing was possibly the cannibals. A wonderful description there, even in such a short amount of text. Out. |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
yeah, describing the cannibals was my favorite part to write, and yeah I could've written more, but I just didn't have the time....
__________________
Give me love, give me peace on earth, give me light, give me life, keep me free from birth, give me hope, help me cope, with this heavy load, trying to, touch and reach you with, heart and soul. --George Harrison |
|
||||
|
I think the first paragraph could have been more active not only in vocabulary, so too in imagery. And how did your character come to keep track of his ‘time’ on the island?
Also, the trek through the island possibly gathering wood for a large fire to attract rescuers, that too could have been more dramatic. Possible say something like…The boy expected me to find his mother and save her. Who is this person the boy speaks with? And how did he and his mother come to find themselves on this cannibalistic island? There could be fewer ‘I’s. Also (for me) your sentences seem too simple. There could be more dramatics within concerning action, dialogue, and emotion. The trek through the jungle…a lot more imagery, action and emotion could be illustrated here. The visual of the cannibals’ huts…a lot more imagery could be illustrated here. I think your tenses are incorrect in their execution. Where is the more visual active ‘hunt’ for the boy and his new companion? Where is the more visual of a roasting fire pit? You are not only presenting vague actions, but you are rushing them also. The ‘escape’ was too vague (imagery/action/emotion). Where is the sigh of relief? A jovial laughter in the face of death? The Miss should be capitalized. A very surprise ending finding out the ‘cannibal situation’ was only a movie set. But I still stand by the vagueness of your write; imagery, action, and emotion out pour. I give a rating of 2/5.
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
Um, thanks? It's a short story. Emphasis on the short. I would of/can elaborate, but wouldn't it then be more of a longer read?
__________________
Give me love, give me peace on earth, give me light, give me life, keep me free from birth, give me hope, help me cope, with this heavy load, trying to, touch and reach you with, heart and soul. --George Harrison |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
This is an interesting idea and it has lots of potential. In certain spots you write very well and in others you rush it too much.
Here's some specific "dings" I noticed: Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I find it hard to believe that the MC would just waltz straight into a camp of cannibals without even attempting to sneak up. She's going into very dangerous, very deadly place. At least attempt to be unseen. It's also hard to imagine they even could walk straight into the camp. Tribes are always protecting their land and leave scouts in the surrounding area to insure nobody could do what the MC did. A tribe could be wiped out by another hostile one if they were so lax in security. Rena is entirely right in pointing out that more time on detail and description of action is needed. You replied that it is supposed to be a short story. It's always a battle to maintain a balance between description and length. This is something every writer faces and it's tough. A way to maintain the balance is simplify the plot and reduce the number of characters. Then you can flesh out the details of the action and description and still end with a short story. Keep at it and let your ideas flow. Don't worry about length so much (I'm saying this to "me" as much as I am to you). Let the story be what it is, then come back and trim the fat later. Thanks for sharing your work!
__________________
Writer of silly stories |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
Hi there,
The story has potential, but there are a couple things to point out. Why did the girl not explore? She was sitting there for 27 days and did not go find food or no one found her? Also, descriptions are a bit lacking and seem jumpy for some parts. And the girl, when she found out a woman was being roasted alive - her reaction wasn't very realistic...I think she should have been completely mortified and it justseemed to not phase her. Even the kid did not seem very shocked by the fact his mother died (even though it was fake) However, I applaud the twist with the movie set. It made me smile as I saw it unfolding and I laughed a little So nice concept but some things seem vague and need more detailing and more realistic reactions. But otherwise good work. Keep at it.
__________________
"Trust is like a mirror, once you break it you never look at it the same way."
|
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
I agree with the people above me, even for a short story, it's a bit short and vague, try looking for sentences that aren't very well built and rewrite them.
Also, how old is this girl? If she's 13 and under, I might understand her wanting to try what her father said, but any older and I'm sure common sense would have prevailed. I think you need to find an alternative, such as a careless deck hand leaving soapy water on the deck near the railing and the woman slipping over the edge, or maybe the oysters disagreed with her and she was puking over the side when the ship hit a nasty wave, sending her after the previous contents of her stomach. Also, as it has been mentioned, but not elaborated on, 27 days of doing nothing? She'd better hope to hell that the spot where she landed has a freshwater pond with a ton of fish in it beside a cave with a stove in it. She has no water, shelter or food, and after the first few days at the most, I guarantee you that she's going for a walk. 27 days is almost a month, and what you told us, as the narrator, is that she just sat there, doing nothing. I hate to break it to you, but your character's dead, rotting, and the animals are picking her clean. Don't get me wrong, it's an interesting read but, I'm sad to say, I can't call it good in the face of so many inconsistencies. If you take the advice offered by all these people and build on it, you may have something really good. In the mean time, I only offer a 2/5. If you do up a nice rewrite, I'll revise the score to a 4 or a 5.
__________________
Don't throw everything on the fire of life at once. If you do, you'll have nothing left to feed it and will be left to watch the fading coals in memory of what used to be. ~The Masked Musician Stories Mania's annoying adopted younger Brother |
|
||||
|
Re: Trapped
Well. . . I think that it has been covered that one would not sit in the same place for 27 days so I won't just tell you about it. I thought that it would be better if you just had 'she fell off ship. finds boy next day. period.' i thought that you could have described more at some parts but with a short piece it was brillant. . . Oh and though common sense SHOULD have taken over I can totally imagine a person walking on the rails so no worries there. . . good job with the surprise ending!!!
![]()
__________________
If YOU don't talk to your CAT about catnip, who will? |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|