| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy-Day 1
Perhaps at the beginning to avoid the repetition ..'an old smell of rotten/rancid fish.. or other.
__________________
Did you know...points are up for grabs....just for entering... 250 - LIMERICK, CFPC, 55, EMWE, 1000 - TotM, 1000 WC 100 - VOTING IN A CONTEST POLL, YES, JUST VOTING! ![]() Comp/Challenges FFFC CFPC 1000-Word Challenge Limerick ToTM EMWE GQC |
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
fixed. i think thats the shortest critique u ever gave me
__________________
Why are you looking at this sig? You should probably be looking at the post.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
I felt that the story was a bit sensational. For instance: the part where Johnny literally tears a guy apart when he is escaping from the bar. I realize you want to portray Johnny as an expert in his field, but this is almost too much. Another thing that perplexed me was the tone of the story. I couldn't tell if you wanted us, the readers, to take this story completely seriously or view it as an exaggerated action flick. For example, the part where Johnny's ride explodes and he flies conveniently out through the windshield, somehow unharmed, detracts from the realism of the story overall.
Overall, this is fairly well written. The dialogue is above average and your descriptions work. One thing I noticed was that you switched momentarily from third person to first person, halfway through. I'm not sure if this was intentional, but if it was I didn't get your reasoninig behind it.
__________________
What but design of darkness to appall?-- If design govern in a thing so small. |
|
|||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
It was okay, not perfect. Although there were some good parts inserted, various mistakes were made. Good job.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
Actually that was exactly what I was going for Ambrose, I wrote this after watching Kill Bill for the hundreath time.
__________________
Why are you looking at this sig? You should probably be looking at the post.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
it was just ok for me
__________________
Not everything makes sense , except to those who have lived it |
|
|||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
lately i havent been review a whole lot of stories on here (i love the site, but college apps are a bitch) but this story caught my eye.
the diction is excellent in my opinion. a little clunky in the first paragraph. perhaps edit the staccato of the first few sentances into something more fluid, something with more flowing imagery. i liked the kind of over-the-top violence to it. it reminded me of john woo's hardboiled, or his game, Stranglehold. however, the bane of the game and of the story remain the same. it seems that, while the action parts are good, and the immediate rising action is good (i like him holding the body with his foot), it kindof feels a bit contrived against the rest of the story. however, what i did like about the action was how instantly it started. the sort of way that johnny suddenly becomes uncaged is awesome. the switch between third person (i remember it happening twice [my gun...we passed underground]) also, some redundant sentances in the beginnings of paragraphs kind of made that whole section feel a little bit off. try using other words besides "pale" and "paper white" to describe johnny. also, switching between johnny and "the figure" is a little bit too seamless. it led me to believe there was a split personality for a little while, then realized the two were synonymous. also, and this is more of a styleistic remark, try describing the gunfight in deep detail. it will slow it down, making each person johnny kills important and interesting. as a whole, this is a great story. the action is all there, and the characterization is good. really just a bunch of little things, rather than one big thing, could use correcting. let me know what you think
__________________
"I did this to myself" -Comeback Kid "Never Back Down; Never Give in." -Throwdown "This is my therapy." -Bane "This time I trust no one." -Cold War "Only once you've lost everything are you free to do anything." - Fight Club |
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
The story lost me. Who waz tellin the story?
__________________
"It's only a matter of time before everyone realizes that things will get better. Just look to God, he's got all of the answers." |
|
|||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
First of all, the narrator switches from someone/thing watching from the sidelines (a ghost or whatever) to being Johnny. Third paragraph, dark orange, you use Johnny and my in the same sentence. I'm guessing what happened was you wrote this first person maybe and then went back through and switched it. I do this too, and I usually miss a few places. No harm done. Third para, green, was sweating, instead of sweated. Also, add a coma after was sweating, and Bart... Third para, red isn't really needed. The following two sentences explain why he kicked and held his foot there. Third para, brown, you use "he" to describe two different men in back to back sentences. Need to put in a Johnny or Bart or both so the reader doesn't have to reread or stop to figure out which is which. Third para, blue, this sentence comes off rough. Loud is used twice. Maybe cut it down to: In a purposely loud voice, "Well to...etc Fourth para, purple, these four sentences really break up the flow of the story and the start of the action scene. I would suggest going back through and smoothing them out. Something like this: It seemed to him like his footsteps were actually audible in the booming bar, causing him to glance back. Bart was bleeding from the mouth. Oh how he hoped nobody would notice, but just as his hand reached out for the door, two strong hands seized him, pulling him back. Fourth para dark green, this is a run-on sentence. Put a period or a semi-colon after "kicked in." Fourth para red, this paragraph will be fine without those three words. If you absolutely need the visual of a man flying backwards work it into the next sentence like: As the man crashed through a table, the room erupted in gunfire. Which leads me to my next suggestion, "shots erupted from all over" doesn't carry a lot of impact. The wording is a little awkward or something, I can't quite place my finger on it. I would start a new paragraph at: "Johnny kicked...." and combine the next sentence: Johnny kicked over a table sliding his back against it for cover. 4th para yellow, bodies 4th para orange, there is a "then" in each of these sentences. Also, I agree with Ambrose. Maybe say Johnny ripped out the guys throat instead of ripping him literately apart. One thing that bugged me was...he exits the club and he is safe... Nobody came after him? I mean he calls and waits for the guy to pick him up. The only explanation I could think of was all the shotting was not being directly solely at Johnny. That once one shot went off people started firing at anyone else with a gun. If so, make that more apparent. The last two paragraphs are also like Ambrose said, a little unbelievable. Johnny flies out of a car I think just exploded, (breaks through a windshield?) into a dumpster (which are usually in allies) and seems unhurt. However, its your story, if that's the way you want it. So be it! There are a few things in the last paragraph, "The driver was ran at him with a handgun." (take out the was) ", and blasted the driver across the street." Do you mean he shot the driver from across the street or he shot the driver and the driver flew across the street. I would start a new paragraph and have the first sentence be something along the lines of Johnny collecting himself from the dumpster to find his cell phone still in one piece on the pavement. ### I know I'm being pretty critical with all this and I apologize, but this story interests me and the beginning was pulling me in, then the story got bumpy and I spent too much time rewording things in my head to enjoy it. What I mean to say is, I like the story and I like where it is going. The main character is interesting and the plot surrounding him is intriguing. The flow is pretty good regardless. Mechanics get a little sloppy, but I pretty bad with grammar and what not myself. It is just that I think you could bring out more potential in this story, because I see more. Good job, and please remember this is just the opinion of one person. Don't use it if you don't want to, and hopefully I didn't offend you.
__________________
"All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players: they have their exits and their entrances; and one man in his time plays many parts, his acts being seven ages.." - William Shakespeare |
|
|||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
For me, the action felt a bit choppy. I would love to read a more in depth assassination scene. When Johnny is put through the windshield, don't you think that may kill him?
|
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
This is the making of a good series. Sadly, I noticed a few errors. Like:
Quote:
Also... Crap! I lost the mistakes. Sorry. You may want to read the story again. Good Story and I can't wait to hear the rest.
__________________
According to Dante's Divine Comedy, Flatterers are condemned to the Eigth Circle of Hell. Ah crap. |
|
|||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
I liked the different moods in the story, and the way it changed from first person to third person. It also reminded me of the comic Johnny The Homicidal Maniac.
__________________
Whoever said anything was possible, obviously never tried to slam a revolving door... |
|
|||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
It was a nice action flick, all in all. The sudden switch from third to first person confused me somewhat. You also lost me several times there with those missing commas and some odd sentences(I think Razor pointed those out). The plot was good enough, nothing extraordinary but still good. I'd like to see the sequels to this. Some work to do with grammar, but it didn't ruin the reading experience. I did like the main character though.
Anyways, please do keep writing. |
|
||||
|
Re: Johnny Boy - Day 1
Did you mean ‘dirtied glass,’ A fat man with a scraggily beard picked up a dirtied glass.?
What about saying ‘trickled,’ A thick red liquid trickled out the corner of his mouth.? What about...The sun (had been) exceptionally bright that afternoon.? I think you should use the word aroma or scent and stench to substitute ‘smell.’ You mean ‘its,’ here...A red car flew across the street with its passenger door (maybe swung) open.? Perhaps consider using albino in place of ‘pale man.’ Or some other words describing 'pale.' Maybe say ‘halted,’ The car finally halted in front of a cheap apartment building.? Also consider giving more actions to a car that maybe screeching, tires smoking as suddenly the screaming breaks are slammed down hard. I think the ‘furniture scene’ could be expanded upon more. The whole ‘setting’ of the apartment could be described in more detail. What was Johnny doing as he took/listened to the man over the phone. Did you play with the telephone cord? Observes his fingers? Was he sweating or removing his clothing? Some of these additional details I think would be beneficial to your story. I think you should find a way to emphasize Boss. Bold it or italic. Just make it stand out that He is the one in control. The explanations of the two weapons too could be more in depth in imagery and usage, I think. Maybe show more about the two men in the car and their behavior of them as they all drove downtown. Perhaps illustrate the ‘eyeing’ of the target as he was scooping/surveying the bar’s interior and its occupants. Saying that ‘Finally, Johnny seen the target,’ is too simple in words and imagery. Possibly...He began to laugh so loudly that the food once stuffed/shoved into his mouth spewed out his yellow lined lips. OR something similar. I think you are losing your tense execution when you say, ‘He seen,’ I believe you should say ‘He had seen...’ Did you mean ‘his,’ Johnny drew his gun under the counter.? Maybe something like...Luckily, he didn’t fall like the prior afternoon’s target.? A hitman wouldn’t bring an extra magazine with him? That seems a bit unbelievable to me. You have too much spacing between ‘out’ and the ending period. I think...Bart’s in a bad mood today. OR...Brad’s in a foul mood today. And add some action to the speaker. The driver ran/rushed at him with a handgun. (The original sentence is incorrect.) You could combine some sentences and extend others...Johnny flew out the windshield and landed in a dumpster. The whole story for me as an action tale could be more fluent and suspenseful with activities and imageries. For me there were gaps in story that could have been more finely tuned so for the original idea I will give a rating of 2/5.
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|