| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
|||||||||||||||||||
|
Re: The Smell Of Love
I can't put my finger on it, but I felt there was something missing here. Your descriptions were pretty good. Not something that would completely blow me away, but yes, I liked them. You began this well; the mention of the smell and everything else. It was described in a lovely manner. Good description there; I could feel it. I could feel your protagonist getting all sick and my stomach too started churning. Lol.
As I said, you started well, but somewhere in between you lost the original thought. I've seen better work from you (That Attraction Program was really good) and I know you have it in you. Just keep you focus and go through whatever you've written. Run your file on a spell checker. A grammar checker too could be used. Now coming to the errors here, let me first say that I'm not stalking you. Lol. Ok... I'll try to go through this fast. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
He had no more strength left to run now, anyway. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
He breathed through his nostrils when he was able to, and again the stench returned. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
He would have to get used to it soon and was thankful for a bit of practice. The comma before 'and' is a personal choice. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
A few of your sentences were absolutely fantastic. But as soon as I started sinking into their depth, they reached an awkward and abrupt end. Some examples: Quote:
Quote:
I think that's about it. Your writing is pretty good. You have a thing with descriptions; the 'sick' scene was very well done, and then the sentences I have highlighted here. Good work, but you can definitely do a lot better. |
|
||||
|
Re: The Smell Of Love
Haha, wow. Thank you. I'm trying, but I seem to be losing my ability to correct mistakes. I'm trying, but I'll try a little harder.
__________________
"People are ignorant. They'll feel better as long as someone is punished." -Final Fantasy VII |
|
||||
|
Re: The Smell Of Love
That was a fine description i must say! You work very well with images, emotions and continuity. Of course, i'm not sure if you have decided yet what is the original idea. It seems to me that you have illustrated the "lonelyness of the long distance runner" and yes i could smell it all the way! What i can't find in your story is the purpose, the motive. I believe that it is absolutely important to let us know more things about your character. You've got the image right, you've created a fine situation but there is no plot in your story. If it was the scene description of a screenplay then everything would be fine. In fact, why don't you try write it again in a screenplay format, but first work on the plot.
|
|
||||
|
Re: The Smell Of Love
Yeah, this was inspired by pretty much nothing more than a dead puppy on the side of the road. It smelled gross, but I couldn't get over the fact that it was dead. That just kind of... it hurt. The poor thing never had a chance at life. I wondered if other people had seen it and laughed, so I got a plastic bag, picked it up, and buried it properly. The next day there was two more where the first had been. They weren't flat or squished, just dead. I thought someone might be killing them, and I wrote what I thought someone who knew death would think if they came across it. It's not much, I just needed to write my feelings out because those puppies were making me depressed.
(Yes, I gave those two a proper burial next to their brother. No, I didn't see anymore dead puppies.)
__________________
"People are ignorant. They'll feel better as long as someone is punished." -Final Fantasy VII |
|
||||
|
Re: The Smell Of Love
First a few laughs concerning the ‘comma situation.’ And lets remember too for reassurance that the editors/reviewers are all here to point out and assist in the punctuation department…lols (I too have the same problem so I mention it.)
Now for my thoughts (though I think there will not be much), Nupur has ‘picked u apart like a bloody bone.’ LOL Maybe…That smell pierced his nose; his flaring nostrils instinctively flared as that odor penetrated his every thought until it became his mind’s only thought.(OR something similar.) Was his ‘want(s)’ greater than the ‘need(s)’ for a vehicle? One always desires/wants a car, but one needs a vehicle to carry him/her to places of employment and other. Did u mean ‘than,’ here…but wanted one more now (than) that ever, working or not, Y does ur character need to ‘hide away from a smell?’ Or are u being metaphorical? U could describe the ‘smell’ with more descriptive words; revolting, repulsive, pungent , nauseating odor/scent/aroma/stench. (For me) the first paragraph is awkwardly written; ur being repetitive, but not in a good way. Ah, the second sentence under the first paragraph is too awkward. The detection of raw oysters stabbed his sinuses warning him that something more dangerous was to come.(OR something similar.) Did u mean something like…The cold bitterness of raw oysters followed him so too did its ‘smell.’ The decomposition of their graying flesh made his stomach wretch. ‘Vomit (perhaps describe its color, thickness…)’ climbed through his belly heading towards a gasping mouth; if his throbbing legs muscles hadn’t distracted him, his twinging* stomach would’ve erupted a pile of it.(OR something similar.) I ask this only in ur original, the sentence seems to say/illustrate that his legs weren’t as tired as his hurling stomach. What was the ‘dirty?’ He dropped to his knees and spewed the remaining contents of his stomach onto the dirty____(the dirtied what?)? The paragraph itself too could be more descriptive regarding the smells, looks, perhaps touch/feel and the actions of expulsion their of. Maybe…He stood on shaking legs trying to swallow the stinging acidic vomit that his stomach had erupted/created.(OR something similar.) Also to give more imagery, why not in the following rather than saying ‘stinking,’ say bubbling/oozing vomit? I think ‘oyster,’ could be replaced by ‘muscles.’ There are other words describing ‘oysters,’ but I don’t know them all. Shouldn’t it be…If this was not what death smelled like, but what a body smelled like, he (would have enjoyed) would enjoy this moment. (And this whole sentence is awkward.) Y would one ‘adjust to the smell(s) of death?’ U mean, He turned, though only for a (moment’s) moments glance, U mean, but he would the (next) net place. U mean…Jack’s ten year old form began to disappear into the *setting/sinking sun as he took a step, then another walking towards the place he would call ‘his new home.'(OR something similar.) I’m perplexed by ur tale. I understand possibly that ur character has become a killer in order to feel/smell the ‘love,’ of burning flesh/blood. Its all just very complex for me. And ur delivery for such a psychological/intense tale…the descriptions were too dull and too simple. I give a rating…2 of 5.
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|