| Arcade | Chat | Podcast | Radio | Submit |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|||||||
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
|
||||
|
Re: Untitled Story: Part One
Quote:
Ok, I've now read the story through, and my first impression, like it was with your previous entry, is that this is clean. Your writing style is really good, really neat, and pretty polished. Hardly any jagged egdes at all as far as the writing style or narration is concerned. I normally make it a point to review, among other things, characterization. However, with such a small story, which probably serves more or less as an introduction to the characters, or possibly as the middle part of a longer story (the part where the hero meets the heroine), it's really rather difficult to comment on the characterization, as there really is not much to go by. However, I can already say that you've got the basics right. The heroine is drop-dead gorgeous, as one would expect her to be. And the hero is probably young, inexperienced but a quick learner, and righteous, very righteous. Yet, he doesn't display the headfastness of rushing into a situation because it's the right thing to do. So, already your characters intrigue and invite, making the reader want to get further acquainted with them. Characterization is not the only thing that builds up to make the reader want to read the next part. The ending is clearly a cliffhanger ending, and it's not always to leave your audience hanging like that (some of them can get pretty bugged), but since this part is not so long, it works. It manages to keep the reader's interest, instead of creating a feeling of "Wow, I just read through 10 pages and all I get is a f---ing cliffhanger at the end!" If there's one critical thing I would say, it's probably a couple of things about the woman. For one thing, I would choose another word rather than "woman". Using it once is ok, but I think I'd prefer "lady" or some other word like that. Generally, the word "woman" appears to be used in somewhat negative connotations. "Lady" seems better, no? But that's entirely a matter of opinion, and it's not a big deal by any means. I was also going to mention about how he had to blink to notice the array of men around her and later, had to study her face intently to notice the gashes. In my opinion, an array of huge, dirty men would have been spotted the first time around itself, and if the wounds on her face were as deep as gashes, he should have noticed them without having to study her face. But the way you've written it is just fine, actually, and this is a really minor point. Actually, almost ignore it. I just said it because I was thinking it, and to make my critique as detailed as I could. Bottom line, good job! I am waiting for parts 2,3,4,5...
__________________
And everybody's got a right to a will to want to live And a right to want to die ~ "Ejector Seat Reservation", Swervedriver. |
|
||||
|
Re: Untitled Story: Part One
Quote:
Minor nitpicky in a wonderful vignette. You realize, of course, that you'll have to finish this now, Kit. You have piqued my interest. I want to know more about what's going on here. In addition to being a really good writer, you're also a really good storyteller. Excellent suspense here, with poetic language and images to carry the tale along. I get an image of a fantasy heroine like Red Sonja, perhaps in her early days where she was a young girl still learning the ropes. I can easily see you playing the part in a film version. All the pieces are in place for a rip-roaring fantasy tale; even the name "Rowen" is laden with images of sword and sorcery. It's quite a feat when you can generate that kind of interest in a short piece. Looking forward to more. You told me this story had been following you around for a couple of days, Kit. I'm glad you let it catch you!
__________________
Where you been lately? There's a New Kid in Town. Everybody loves him, don't they? Now he's holding her, and you're still around, Oh, my, my - There's a New Kid in Town. ~ Eagles ~
|
|
||||
|
Re: Untitled Story: Part One
Thanks guys. You are my "knights in shining armor" her at SM.
Thanks for the notice of the spelling error Rick. As usual...lol. Ok now I really do feel pressure to work on this. Gurdit.....thanks.
__________________
Do not overlook the obvious solution... |
|
||||
|
Re: Untitled Story: Part One
Most excellently written! Your descriptions are very good and they help set the stage very well. You've got a very interesting character there and a compelling heroine. My only complaint: it's too short. Looking forward to more!
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||
|
Re: Untitled Story: Part One
What's this? Prose? By Kristen?
Very Good Work! Imagery was excellent: Quote:
I like the foreshadowing and developing action, too. Like Gurdit said, a little more characterization for the protagonist would be nice, though with something in first person I find that difficult to pull off, especially with something this short. Overall, Great Job! I look forward to more.
__________________
According to Dante's Divine Comedy, Flatterers are condemned to the Eigth Circle of Hell. Ah crap. Last edited by Zoidberg; 09-12-2008 at 09:22 AM. Reason: One More Thought |
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
I disagree Rick. "That may be true in neighbor and weight, and on weekends and holidays and all throughout May, but you'll always be wrong no matter what you say."
Back to the story though, iron silk? You mean the blade was silky smooth; or the sheath was soft and velvety? I got lost on that metaphor. Maybe cuz I'm blond but I doubt that. Now everything is starting to make more sense, plus there is a little conflict now. You'll have to tell me when the next chapter comes out.
__________________
|
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
Ahhh...Tim. You crack me up!
BTW...thank you! Iron Silk= The blade was made of iron but smooth as silk. Does that make sense? Glad you like this so far...especially since you're urgings got me to start writing it. Part three should be here shortly..I just have to finish it.
__________________
Do not overlook the obvious solution... |
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
So this is the story with the kids and the underground bunker and the government is controlling them all? I thought it'd be a little more in the future after an apocolyptic event or something.
Now it all makes sense with the metaphor. And thank you.
__________________
Last edited by timtornado3721; 10-12-2008 at 01:21 PM. |
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
No...this isn't that story...that story still needs to fester in my brain for a bit more..
But you said to write something that wasn't poetry, so here it is! Ready or not!
__________________
Do not overlook the obvious solution... |
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
Before I go looking for things to complain about let me start by saying, this is the most well written piece I've read in the fantasy section, and I'm actually pretty sure I've read published pieces that were less pollished.
Well if I have to find something to complain about it might be that you get a bit wordy at times, but that may just be my personal taste, I just felt that sometimes your descriptions were a bit heavy and disrupted the flow of the piece. You have an okay hook with the interesting description of the sword and the reader wondering why he's to weak to fight, but you may wanne make the mystery of the sound through the wood be the first thing that is desribed. Also I think it may be a good idea to go a bit more into his past with Rowen so we get to know the character and feel sympathy and worry about him before he stomps into battle or the like. The place where I thought the piece really dragged was when there were so many wordy desriptions about the sound and how he crept through the woods, I think it could be done better, someone above mentioned foreshadowing, but that's actually what I thought it lagged, we didn't have some disturbing guess about what would happen when he found where the sound originated. well there were a few other things, but some of them were also mentioned by others, but it's small things. well no matter what this is very interesting, I'll go and read the other parts and see if you can keep it up.
__________________
GIVE ME PEN, PAPER AND SOLITUDE.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
Interesting! Very nice hook there at the beginning with the "iron silk", it really grabs a reader by the shirt front.
I found myself wondering who this character is and why he's come to be in the middle of the forest hiding. I've read books that begin with the ending and then start off to tell the tale and eventually end up at the ending again, but this one almost seems to start in the middle of something. Is it your intention to bring it full circle? It was very clean, you did a fantastic job editing and proofing. I'm going to disagree with Arnkilt, I'm one who doesn't think that you CAN have too many descriptives in a story. The more you have the more you feel like you are part of the story and you've don a wonderful job with that. I'm looking forward to chapter two! Off I go.
__________________
GO VOTE ON A CHALLENGE OR WE'LL TATTOO THIS Quote:
|
|
||||
|
Re: Firetales: Part One
Lovely stuff, though a few minor nit-picky things to mention I'm afraid:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Anyway, moving on to the next part! edit: God dammit I sound like the microsoft word 'assistant'. So sorry for that. The only difference is I'm actually right.
__________________
Do not lie to the Chair Leg of Truth, for it is wise and terrible.
Last edited by Beagle; 19-12-2008 at 02:36 PM. |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|