| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
A very interesting piece. I admired how you were able to capture Jabob's feelings about his situation in a way that didn't make the reader evoke immense pity for him but rather helped us to understand what he was feeling and why. Pardon me as I edit this...
"Fat drops of rain were hammering the window" Use an active tense vice passive, more enthralling for the reader, which is important in an opening sentence. "Unwillingly he opened the door" Nebulous comma! Insert after Unwilling. "He doesn't care about his stupid T-shirt. He doesn't need it, he doesn't want it, he refuses to wear it!" Stick to past tense for better flow. "in the mud, and jump on it," Insert "to" infront of jump for nicer flow. Ick second thought...it's decent the way it is but the change wouldn't hurt. "He opened the window the window and crawled " Delete one of "the window"'s, please. "He pulled of his pajamas" "Off" not of Good work.
__________________
It's all just tinsel. Under the spotlights, everything sparkles.
Last edited by 'Ginnis; 27-08-2007 at 06:11 PM. |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
Thanks a lot!
I changed most of things, except the first sentence, it just doesn't sound good when I change it. And I'm not so sure about the sentendce I changed into the past tense either, doesn't it sound weird now? |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
Personly i think jacob needs some help * HELP IN ISLE FIVE HELP IN ILSE FIVE*
the story good, the ending though needs a little more, it was kinda all over the place. |
|
|||
|
Re: The Attic
I thought this was terrific. Your use of language is very creative -- and exciting.
Points: There is a sudden shift in tone in the last few sentences. My guess is that you'd done your thing and wanted to move on. I wish I had something specific to offer by way of example, but I would rewrite it so it doesn't sound like you're slamming on the brakes. The creative language makes this occasionally a little difficult to follow, primarily because I'm sometimes not sure if you're doing something stylistic or just making a small error. For example, the phrase "said calm quiet voice." If you mean "she said in a calm quiet voice," it should be written that way. But to personify, to say that "calm quiet voice" actually spoke, is really cool. I wonder, too, how it would read if you rewrote the entire piece in the present tense. Might be an interesting experiment. Here are a few suggestions, found in order in the story: rip off his clothes (instead of cloth) to let the rain hammer him (remove on) He sighed (kill so instead,) hero wants, isn't it? (instead of wanted) really brave, Jacob. (put in comma) And to jump on it. (add to) How would it look if (delete like) down his neck. (delete within few seconds) Now, what would that feel like (change how to what) drop out and fall... (change fell to fall) shabbiest t-shirt (delete he found) he was that fly (add that) |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
The story didn't amount to anything for me. I didn't get why Jacob was in the attic, why he wanted to clean himself off so badly, or why he hated the shirt his step father gave him. I'm guessing he simply he hated his step father but at the same time Jacob seemed a bit weird to begin with--I mean, who sits in the attic all day and watches the rain? All of the self-deprecating language that he uses makes be believe he's depressed which would explain why he thinks about jumping off the roof later on. I also kind of thought it had to do with him thinking his mother was dirty for going with another man that wasn't his father. Could be totally off on that one. Also the way Jacob reacts to everything seems a bit sporadic: at one point his face is screwed up in anger as he takes the shirt outside and then the next it's funny and then finally he gets a cold chill from realizing what he's just done. A cold chill from stomping on a shirt? I can see killing the neighbor's cat, but a shirt? That seemed a little played up. The ending was OK with Jacob finally escaping and all. But the beginning needs more character development.
__________________
What but design of darkness to appall?-- If design govern in a thing so small. |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
Alloallo3: Thank you very much. I guess it's small part of "creative language" (at least that's wahat I wanted and tried) but also of bad English.
I meant "calm quiet voice" in Jacob's head.... it's not really "he", or "she". I feel that the ending needs rewriting... but whatever I try, doesn't seem to fit... Ambrose - well, yes. Jacob is depressed... but most people I showed this guessed that he is an abused child - by his father. And his mother obviously knows about it, but doesn't really help. That's why he was depressed, that's why he felt dirty, that's why he vented his anger and hate on poor innocent T-shirt. And that's why he was so afraid later. Exactly how he was abused... that's up to you, a reader, to figure out. Some people said to me it must be sexual abuse, some thought "only" psichycal terror. Anything is fine with me.
__________________
"Dear me, dear me," say I. "These are not the times to be writing books, Don Eligio, even fool books like mine. Of literature I must begin to say what I have said of everything else: 'Curses on Copernicus!'" Late Mattia Pascal Last edited by Aiculik; 04-03-2008 at 07:23 AM. |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
It seems sort of that Jacob isn't all there, ya know what I mean?
I didn't quite get the ending. I did like how you described Jacob's feelings. Pretty good story. Your descriptive writing is very good. What happened in the ending? Jacob disappeared? I do almost feel bad for Jacob though. The way you wrote was good; story was iffy.
__________________
According to Dante's Divine Comedy, Flatterers are condemned to the Eigth Circle of Hell. Ah crap. |
|
||||
|
Re: The Attic
Well, i must say that your story is very interesting. It made me keep on reading because i wanted to know what will happen in the end. So what happened to our protagonist? I'm sure you know the answer, or you are thinking of one! Very well described character and i got a clear picture of his feelings and thoughts. You served that aspect of the story very well. In the end of the story there is a fire! A fire lightened by curiocity! Please, consider writing more! This story can't end like this!
|
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|