| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: The Clairvoyant Detective
A staunch thriller. You had me hooked right to the very end. This could easily be a tv show, or even a movie. It was that good.
But... please tell me that is not the end? This is just the first part, correct? Because I absolutely need to know what is going to happen to the girl. The characters you've created are uncannily lifelike and thoroughly interesting. You simply must continue this. Anyways, excellent, excellent, excellent. You definitely have a knack for this stuff.
__________________
What but design of darkness to appall?-- If design govern in a thing so small. |
|
||||
|
Re: The Clairvoyant Detective
The detective story has to be my favorite so whenever I see one on here I have to check it out and see if it does the genre any justice. I have to say that his was a very nice begining to what I hope will be a longer story. This part was an excellent lead up and I just hope you can make the rest of the story work.
Good luck with this. I look forward to his coming out really good. PS sorry about the 73% I really did think it was better than that, but If I could do math better in my head I wouldn't be writing stories instead. Last edited by Wordsmyth; 15-08-2006 at 06:56 PM. |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] The Clairvoyant Detective
Reviewer Disclaimer: I am not a literary critic, as a matter of fact I never got an "A" in English (usually "B"s) so I don't know the value of my opinions. These are just my impressions and are in no way meant to discount the hard work and effort that you put into your story. I never want to sound pompous, or know it all-ish, if I do, you have my apology. I'm just a guy who likes to read and write. In a give and take environment, in order to offer my writings, I must also give my opinion on others writing efforts. This is only one snook's opinion!
============================== ============================== ======== First ... the nitpicking. ============================== ============================== ======== "I had anticipated hours of surveillance work, mostly watching unfaithful husbands and in some rare cases, wives. I had expected to be dealing with infidelity and missing animals, cheating husbands and missing cats," It seems like this is a little bit redundant. ============================== ============================== ======== Also, I'm seeing the word "had" making what might be too many appearances. In my opinion, the word "had" is the most overused word in writing. I suggest checking every use of "had" and making sure it's really necessary. ============================== ============================== ======== "I'd watched cleaning his backyard and I knew he wasn't a tidy person, ink spills, and yet he never got a drop on himself despite clumsiness I knew he had." This reads awkwardly. How would: "Having watched him work in his his back yard, it was obvious to me that eight hours in a printing press was not a day that had any chance of leaving him spotless, or even tidy for that matter." ... sound to you? ============================== ============================== ======== "...made him an Oscar winner before he thirty." I suspect that you wanted this to read either... "...made him an Oscar winner before thirty." or "...made him an Oscar winner before he was thirty." ============================== ============================== ======== "John Gregory gasped, then laughed mirthlessly and then looked murderously angry." Seems like extreme anger just because some punk private eye is overconfident. ============================== ============================== ======== "He sat down reluctantly his face contorted with rage." Again, seems like extreme anger just because some punk private eye is overconfident. ============================== ============================== ======== Now ... the narrative review. ============================== ============================== ======== If a story starts slow (and this one started a smidge slow) it had better pick up fast. I have the attention span of a 3 year old. You picked up speed fast and wove a very, very nice yarn. The plot was solid. I really took time to think about Mr. Gray's deduction and I feel it is believable, Columbo-like ... but believable! The voice of the story threw me a bit but I think you must be from the UK and I understand that there are subtle differences between the USA English and UK English. It's hard to describe a first person character but you got the pertinent information (Gray's age, background and experience) in quite nicely. A tad more description of Gray's office, though, might have given more insight into your protagonist. What kind of magazines? Computer games? Somehow, I imagine a Rubiks Cube on his desk. Is the Radio playing? What kind of music? All in all, a very nice story. I enjoyed reading it and I look forward to seeing what happens with the missing girl. And again, these are my opinions, and to quote my ex-wife and current girlfriend ... "What the Hell do I know anyway!!"
__________________
... you look like somebody just walked ova' yo grave. Last edited by Lonely Stranger; 11-12-2006 at 03:03 AM. Reason: Adding to review |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] The Clairvoyant Detective
Nicely done! This had a good pace, and excellent voice. And the first paragraph immediately grabs the reader with the foreshadowing about the girl.
Some places I stumbled while reading: Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Those were the only stumbling points. I had to keep reminding myself that this was just an introduction. Since the Gregory case was solved almost before it started, I didn't get the satisfaction of working it out with James. But I told myself the payoff would come later. I realize you're using this to lead into something else, so it couldn't be played out in that way. I'm hoping the rest allows a more gradual discovery, to give the reader something to figure out. Overall, you grabbed and held me. I'm looking forward to seeing how this turns out!
__________________
"We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams." ~ Arthur William Edgar O'Shaughnessy "Be bold and mighty forces will come to your aid." ~ Basil King |
|
|||
|
Re: [PICK] The Clairvoyant Detective
Boss the piece excellent and had an excellent ending good one. Cant wait to read and find if the girl was rescued.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
Re: [PICK] The Clairvoyant Detective
Quote:
I understand that you are expressing emotion here but the exclamation mark is a bit excessive. One would suffice. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
"When did you acquire the painting Mr Gregory?" "When did you acquire the painting Mr. Gregory?" Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Again you are being repetitive about this detective not being a "psychic." The mystery of the kidnapping shall be a very interesting read.
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] The Clairvoyant Detective
You have a gd idea here, but I did find it a hard read. I found you supplied lots of info in a very matter of fact way which I thought marred the flow. What are the characters thoughts and feeling towards the past memories and ppl?
I liked the first paragraph starting the story. From there; Quote:
the little bald headed man...etc Describe a bit more; allow the personality to develop though his descriptions of ppl and situations. Other wise I like the intriguing possibilities you are weaving with this story.
__________________
Time; an elusive element to a creative mind. For the story burns to be expressed, flooding the mind, seeking an outlet. Red brimmed eyes and dark circles fore-tells a deeper story, echoed in a mirrors reflection. - my story. Last edited by xtremelady; 12-08-2007 at 11:06 AM. Reason: spell |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] The Clairvoyant Detective
An excellent piece of work! As 'Lonely Stranger' said, your writing reflects distinct English language. The story really grips you: at every point there is an urge to read on till the end: but the end isn't here yet, is it? At least the synopsis doesn't suggest so.
Everyone in the story judges Mr.Gray, largely as psychic and some as an amateur over-confident individual in his profession. But why doesn't Mr.Gray judge himself? If he does have all his contacts and can solve a case seamlessly without getting off his chair, he should be portraying his youth attitude at the age of 23! Even with the staggering financial situation, his character doesn't show-off the confidence, the courage. Maybe that is what the character is all about, or maybe Mr.Gray changes to save the girl! |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|