| Arcade | Chat | Podcast | Radio | Submit |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|||||||
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools |
Rating:
|
Display Modes |
|
||||
|
WOW *epic applause* very good! I love it! I don't generally read Sci-Fi, but this one had me wrapped up like an asylum patient. I like Victor, he seems to have a god grasp of what's bound to happen. It would make sense that because we're weaker and obviously nowhere near as intelligent as the alien races that we would be nothing but a milestone to their culture. In fact, it would make perfect sense because coming up with all that technology would require massive amounts of resources, after a while they would have to run out(unless they developed some way of recycling all resources).
~~~ I only saw a few issues with the story, just little trips that kinda confused me. The Trillies. Does that refer to the family's surname (if the aliens those sorts of things) or their species? I just thought that that could be clarified, I dunno, maybe it's only me. ~~~ "Will Golic, aka "Shark", crouched in the darkness of an alley" I think you made a little slip with comma placement, just a little booboo. I like to think of the quotation marks as pants and the comma as my... er... "tool." Not saying that it's that small, however, I certainly don't want my "tool" hanging out of my jeans on display for the whole world to see. I think that with this line, you may also want to switch the names around ex. "'Shark,' aka Will Golic, crouched..." Because you refer to him more as Shark, that is who you should introduce him as. It would be another thing if you introduced him with: "His name was Will Gomic, but most just called him Shark." It's just a thought, my mind got kind of mixed up at that part. ~~~ "Gleaming metal teeth shone within its gaping jaws, the gun-metal incisors within easily four inches long." This line paints a very nice picture, but I stumbled, tripped, fell and had to stare at what I tripped on for a minute before I realized what happened. The word that tripped me was "within." A very nice word, but it could be one of two things where you positioned it. My theory was that you were trying to say that the teeth themselves were approximately 4" long. The other way it could be taken is that the teeth inside were easily 4" long. Also, you already used "within once" in that sentence, I'd recommend removing one. Try something like: "Gleaming metal teeth shone within its gaping jaws and the gun-metal incisors were easily four inches long." You will also notice that I replaced the comma with an "and." I'm pretty sure that, when you are only connecting two sentences or phrases, a comma isn't needed. Not necessarily a needed change, I just don't think that it's 100%. All in all, a great read. I'm looking forward to further installments in this little series. If you patch those few things up, the story should run like a nose on steroids
__________________
Don't throw everything on the fire of life at once. If you do, you'll have nothing left to feed it and will be left to watch the fading coals in memory of what used to be. ~The Masked Musician Stories Mania's annoying adopted younger Brother |
|
||||
|
Re: Guarding Terra
Hmmmm.... a mechanical werewolf. The lycanthrope of the future.
Nice concept, eric. I like where you're going with this, and look forward to the next chapter. And i don't think it's too gory - plus, you warned people. Nice job...
__________________
Where you been lately? There's a New Kid in Town. Everybody loves him, don't they? Now he's holding her, and you're still around, Oh, my, my - There's a New Kid in Town. ~ Eagles ~
|
|
||||
|
Re: Guarding Terra
Hey D-Min - You made some great catches.
I fixed the line about the Trillies to read: "...the species formally called Trilli'Ngora, Vic reminded himself...". Hopefully, that will make that clearer. The introduction of Shark has been changed to "Shark, aka Will Golic,..." since that seems to be the correct format for aliases. The part about the fangs was definitely an 'oops' moment. The extra 'within' is probably an artifact from editing. I've changed it to, "Gleaming metal teeth shone within its gaping jaws, the gun-metal incisors reaching four inches long." Thanks so much for the sharp eye and the kind comments. I always appreciate a good eye for detail. Glad you're enjoying it. Hey Vorcla - well, not quite a werewolf, hehehe, but certainly a mechanical wolf. It's got a few fun tricks up its pelt nonetheless. The next chapter is essentially done. I'm holding off for now to be sure it blends well into the still-unwritten chapter three. I'm glad it's not too gory. I just hope that such parts make sense to the story and don't appear to be present *only* for shock value. Thanks much for reading and replying. I really appreciate it.
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||
|
Re: Guarding Terra
Great Job, Ea. This was great.
I enjoyed the whole scenario, about alien tourists and such. The description and workings of the CESR was great. I really liked it. There's not much I can really say. I didn't catch any mistakes. Quote:
Overall, the concept, imagery, and little action have been great. I look forward to the next installment.
__________________
According to Dante's Divine Comedy, Flatterers are condemned to the Eigth Circle of Hell. Ah crap. |
|
||||
|
Re: Guarding Terra
Thanks Dan. I think Earth's first alien visitors are likely to be tourists, visiting us the way Americans visit the hill tribes in Thailand (the ones where women wear stacks of rings on their necks) and stare at them as oddities. I plan for this to be a theme in the coming chapters, where all of humanity is treated as a backwater oddity. But just like Thais, humanity has teeth, and pride. Always be courteous to your host...
The skull-popping image affects me the same way, hehehe. I can visualize it all too clearly in mind, so I had to keep it in there. More to come soon!
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||
|
Re: Guarding Terra
Quote:
On a more critical note, I feel your uses of the word 'alien' in the first couple of lines are a bit generic and don't really show the reader what you mean, at least I found it to be that way. Are we supposed to see silver flying saucers and little green men? This becomes clearer later on but you might want to be a bit more imaginative with the initial descriptions. I love how dangerous and efficiently the CESR-1088/e operates. I was a bit curious as to why it was wolf-shaped when it was of alien origin, did I miss something? In my mind I decided it was because CESR was specifically designed for use on Earth. Wonderfully written and very engaging all in all.
__________________
Do not lie to the Chair Leg of Truth, for it is wise and terrible.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Guarding Terra
Hey Beagle - Thanks for reading. Glad you enjoyed the simile. Once in a while I get lucky and get a good one.
Quote:
Quote:
Thanks for the kind words and the comment.
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
hehehe. Yeah there is. Part 2 has another gory scene but you'll also meet Lolita with a strange talent/curse. Part 3 has no gore at all, just character building. Stay tuned!
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
This looks to be off to a flying start. You've painted the scene well, introducing the parties involved (so far) and building some suspense to be dealt with later. I'm looking forward to continuing on.
Some things that jumped out at me (remember, these are just impressions as I read): Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
1) If this is a one-time thing and the character will never be referenced again, I'd drop the name altogether. Leave him "Shark", without the extraneous detail. 2) If you do need him again, you *could* phrase the above as: Quote:
And I think the last line reads fine as: Quote:
Both the name and "former felon" threw me. (Did he used to be a felon and now no longer is? Has he come clean? Or is that he's "former" period, now being dead?) Regardless of the meaning, it just felt like too many words. And finally: Quote:
All in all, a good read, and I'm looking forward to more in the next installments.
__________________
"We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams." ~ Arthur William Edgar O'Shaughnessy "Be bold and mighty forces will come to your aid." ~ Basil King Last edited by Bluejay; 08-01-2009 at 05:28 AM. |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
Hey Bluejay - I was seriously hoping for a review from you.
Okay, I think I can see how the confusion arises about the difference between CESR-1088/e and the lander it arrived on. I'll try to fix that. I'll be cutting out the unnecessary wordiness regarding Will "Shark" Golic in the piece. His role in the story is to die unpleasantly so a lot of detail about him isn't that important. I'll trim out some details as you suggest. I think I will keep the "former felon" bit, though. It's just a tiny slice of humor. You guessed correctly. It's hard to be a felon when one is longer alive to "fellonate", hehehe, thus the "former" appellation. Thanks so much for you insightful comments. I truly appreciate it!
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
Very cool story so far, ea. I must say that I'm not a huge fan of science fiction writing, but the way you write isn't like typical science fiction. You involve your reader a great deal in your style which give your writing style a uniqueness that I haven't seen before. From what I've read of you, doesn't matter what it is, it is easy to get involved with the story and loose yourself in the environment.
You have a very easy and mellow writing style, it's comfortable for the reader and that is very important, especially when writing about the fantastic. I really didn't see anything that stuck out, I think others may have pointed those things out to you and you fixed it up. A very cool story so I'm gonna move right along to the next part. Excellent work here, ea.
__________________
GO VOTE ON A CHALLENGE OR WE'LL TATTOO THIS Quote:
|
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
Thanks Jim. I really appreciate the comments. I am focusing a lot on making the reading very smooth and easy in this one in particular. It takes a lot of work, but your thoughts easily make it worthwhile. Good to hear that it's working. I hope the coming parts read as easily as this one. Thanks bunches!
Bluejay - I've made some additional edits based upon your recommendations. I've decided to drop the felon and Will Golic parts after all. Additionally, I edited the part introducing CESR-1088/e. I've placed it below for quick review. Quote:
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
|||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
Quote:
"So yeah, an alien ship (you know, the one with blisters and sensors) flew in California today. I tell you, Mary, it landed pretty damn exactly where it wanted to." Ok, admittedly, that's a bad example, but the point I'm trying to make is...why start in a bland way like this? Why not take the name of the ship so we know that it's one specific ship? I might be making a mountain of a mole-hill, but I really think one should have a great start to a story, something that just reaches out and grabs you by the nads and forces you to keep reading. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
The next part about Victor Bantay was really good. Very directly, you one one character involved, and from the way he thinks (and also from your summary), I would say he's your protagonist. We don't get to see much about your character, but this part is so important because it wonderfully tells us about the current setting of the story. I also like how you've highlighted the stealthy goings-on, with the aliens landing a war machine (I presume it's an alien machine), while the humans having "Teams", of which we know nothing yet but the name. Good writing in this part; I have no complaints. I also want to point out that I liked the part about how the younger Trillies skipped sideways everywhere they went. Good observation about how youngsters tend to do things like that. I also like Victor's thought-process—practical and quick. I hope I get to read more about him and his character soon. Moving on to the next part now. Ah, the next piece builds up the tension, eh? Nice, I like it. If there hadn't been so much violence in the writing on SM, this one might have shocked me a little, but now I'm used to it. What I do like, though, is that you've not overdone it. You've spent just the right amount of time and words on describing the action. Good job. I don't think I have much more to offer in terms of a critique right now. This is a relatively short part, compared to some of the many others we have on SM, and the story doesn't progress much. It's more like a display of how things are. If I absolutely HAD to nit-pick at something, I'd say I didn't like Shark's introduction. He got too extravagant an intro for a very minor character. In fact, he needn't have been named at all. Even if he was, he should have been introduced more, perhaps, as a petty thief rather than as "Shark". It's a good thing, though, that you gave him bad teeth, a big knife, and blood-stained hands. Oh, and I guess I ought to mention one more time, that your action-writing is great. Shark's reactions, his muscles failing him, Shark's body crashing heavily against the wall, etc...all have very neat touches. Touché. I hope the critique lived up to your expectations. On to the next part, but not right now...in a while. PS: I read a couple of comments before I posted mine, and yes, I must say that the simile about the talkative cat is really good. Heh! You've got a lot of little gems like this one in there, but I've neglected to highlight them for fear that my critique would become too long. On hindsight, I probably should have, so I'll keep that in mind for the next parts.
__________________
And everybody's got a right to a will to want to live And a right to want to die ~ "Ejector Seat Reservation", Swervedriver. |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
Thanks so much, Gurdit!
Your critique has definitely lived up to my expectations. This is exactly the sort of thing I crave. You and Bluejay are very good at providing explicit details about why you think something is good/bad or right/wrong (and everywhere in between) in a clinical, thoughtful manner. This is the sort of critique I want and need. Feel free to make it as long as you like, even in a PM if you feel appropriate. I've made some changes in the areas you pointed out. Hopefully the first and second paragraphs are less bland now. Bluejay had pointed out the same confusion you mentioned where the difference between CESR-1088/e and the lander were not clear. I thought I had fixed that but obviously not. Argh! So, I've made a few more changes. I think the difference between them is more stark than before. I understand if you have other commitments, but I am looking forward to your critique of the next part. On the other hand, don't rush. I'd like the full brunt of your ideas also. Thanks again!
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
I thought this was a very good first part, really enjoyed reading, got caught up in what was happening. The wolf machine is a very unique entity in the story.
When the machine eats shark, are you intending to say that the wolf runs off of human bodies (aka blood, skin, whatever,) or are you saying it's gathering information like the rover sent to mars? You know, a robot sent from one planet to another in order to learn more about it. Anyhow, a really great beginning, just really got interested in reading the next installment.
__________________
Life is one long, lonely road and who do we have but oursleves to keep us company through the thick and thin. - Me. |
|
||||
|
Re: [PICK] Guarding Terra
Hey Alex - Glad you enjoyed it. CESR can use any biomass as fuel. So, a tree, a clump of petunias, or a gallon of Penzoil would all work for it. This actually gets explained a bit later, but that part isn't posted yet. For now, the machine is accomplishing two goals at once: refueling itself, and eliminating a destabilizing social element (Shark).
Thanks for reading. I look forward to your thoughts in later chapters.
__________________
Your living is determined not so much by what life brings to you as by the attitude you bring to life; not so much by what happens to you as by the way your mind looks at what happens. --Kahlil Gibran |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| mecha, nanotechnology, scifi |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|