| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: statistics
please comment and rate?
__________________
I wish ...straight on into frantic oblivion. Safety. Obscurity. Just another freak, in the freak kingdom. -Hunter S. Thompson |
|
||||
|
Re: Statistics
okay, not bad. The ending was pretty abrupt. The other thing is, doesn't have much of a plot to it. You are just telling us a story. If it is meant to act on our feelings of compassion and sympathy... you didn't build your characters up enough.
First, but a break in between the narration from the American side and the German side. I mean, put in like a --------------- or a ######## and center it. That tells the reader you have changed perspective. I was lost for a second when you made the change because, it looked like you were just starting another paragraph. Now, this is just a suggestion, but you might want to switch back and forth from the very beginning. First the American in wait, and then the Germans moving anxiously forward. Second, really work on making Russell or whoever a more lovable character. In fact a way to take this is endearing the reader to both sides. Then the reader doesn't want either one to die, but atlas they are driven to kill each other. You endear us a little with the back story of Russell, but I really didn't feel much when he died. There was a little more emotion potential at the end with the dad, but that was deflated a little by fact that the dad was dead. You could have Russell sending back letters. The last one reading that he just wants to be like his dad, and maybe have his dad alive to read it. That would be more touching. The mechanics of this were bad. The description wasn't bad... there just wasn't a lot of it. We don't know what any of the characters look like and we know very little about the scenery. Also, there were things in this story that didn't add to it. I know it's stuff you want in there, but its bogging down you story. That's why he was here in France in this stupid war...became part of the fighting 29th, 116th infantry regiment. Russell was put in Able Company with most of his friends from basic. By then, the U.S. had declared war...he just wanted to be back in his town. Blue is fine, orange can go, but you could leave it, and red isn't needed. It extra weight. It doesn't add anything to story. This is just one of many. Really go back through and chop any excess that isn't vital to the story. It's fine if you want to add a little 'lacing' to the enrich the story to endear us to the character, just make sure it does that. Also I suggest more description in the opening. Really make the reader feel like he/she are in a foxhole with Russell. William Russell was a young man of twenty-seven with sandy blond hair and deep blue eyes. In a thick haze of rain, in a country side riddled with mortar indentions, Russell crouched in his mud caked hole two wide by two foot deep. He clutched his wet and muddy M1 close to this chest with the butt resting against the bottom of the mud hole. He squatted facing a forked road that would soon bring a squad of Germans to him. The two yellow bars outlined in green on this shoulder marked him as a Corporal. One rank below his goal when he entered the army. However, at that moment, his goal wasn't what's on his mind. At that moment, Russell was wondering why he had volunteered to come out here with this small strike force, in the cold soaking rain to head off a small strike force of Germans intelligence said was heading their way. Something like that. Really set the mood and hook the reader. In fact at this point, you could swing perspectives and talk about the Germans moving forward not sure why they are out there looking for a convey, etc. Good luck man. It's not bad. However there is room for improvement. This is a good to build off of and improve upon. |
|
||||
|
Re: Statistics
Quote:
This story it isnt ment to tell you that you should feel bad for these guys. you can feel whatever emotion you want while reading this. you dont have to just feel sympathy. The ending was deliberate, and it reflects the title. it ends abruply because the moment these men died, they became nothing more than a statistic. Will Russel here became William Russel, son of a WWI veteren, born 1920, died 1944, ECT. anything human about Will is turned into nothing more than a fact. If you should get one thing out of this story, its that war isnt the overplayed, glorified thing you see in the movies and read in books. war is what is right here on the page; patrol, patrol, enemy encounter, battle for something useless (pavlov's house, road, bridge), patrol, ambush, death.
__________________
I wish ...straight on into frantic oblivion. Safety. Obscurity. Just another freak, in the freak kingdom. -Hunter S. Thompson |
|
||||
|
Re: Statistics
all I was trying to say is... the story isn't very captivating. You read it.. and you really don't feel much at all in the end. The thought about them just becoming statistics doesn't come through.
I'm not trying to be mean. I just didn't feel anything for any of the characters. I was never drawn in as a reader. I felt like I was just reading an historical fiction, about some American guys and some German guys, that had very little significants to it. What I was trying to say before was, that you need to draw the reader in more and make him/her care about the characters more. Right, this reads very matter-factly. It's hard for me as a reader to feel the impact that Russel was unjustly made into a statistic, when I never felt attached to him to begin with. |
|
||||
|
Re: Statistics
w/e man. its not like im angry or anything. you can think whatever you want. i was just tellin you what i thought as i wrote it.
thanks for the imput
__________________
I wish ...straight on into frantic oblivion. Safety. Obscurity. Just another freak, in the freak kingdom. -Hunter S. Thompson |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|