| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools |
Rating:
|
Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
Very cool story. As I mentioned, great character development peppered with some breathtaking imagery.
Well done! Edits look good. |
|
||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
i agree. characters were great, which is usually the first thing i look for. as far as the imagery, i wouldnt say it was BREATHTAKING, but it was good. very good. i couldn't see any major mistakes, only 2 spelling errors (i think). all and all, kudos
__________________
I wish ...straight on into frantic oblivion. Safety. Obscurity. Just another freak, in the freak kingdom. -Hunter S. Thompson |
|
||||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
Loved it. Very solid, great characterization. You have everything you need here and nothing you don't. The usual nitpicks:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|
||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
Thanks guys! Much appreciated in-put!
__________________
It's all just tinsel. Under the spotlights, everything sparkles.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
Thoroughly enjoyed that, after the epic beginning and the bike, scenery etc i thought it was going to become twee but that chracter wouldn't let it.....great read!
__________________
Did you know...points are up for grabs....just for entering... 250 - LIMERICK, CFPC, 55, EMWE, 1000 - TotM, 1000 WC 100 - VOTING IN A CONTEST POLL, YES, JUST VOTING! ![]() Comp/Challenges FFFC CFPC 1000-Word Challenge Limerick ToTM EMWE GQC |
|
||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
While Reading
"Assuming you were just a few feet off and your fall increased by quite a few more hundreds of feet and instead of being an omelet on the road you found yourself food for the fish. Most probably decapitated food for the fish." The last sentence is cumbersome, and confusing. "it had most indubitably" Poor word choice with indubitably, almost comical. "letting the dust fly from her tires like the flames of anger she could not subdue inside herself." the similie is tacky and forced Analysis Narration- Your tone fits in with your characters mood, which is definitly good. I like the escapisim of the bike which is great. I like how you build that feeling of escapisim with your narration (the majority of your story now focusing on its subject directly, but instead indirectly with the motercycle). This was one of the strongest points of your story. You use some brilliant imagery, without becoming oppssed with it. Less of this: "A few scattered clouds blanketed the diamonds that lay on the velvet sheet of the night sky." More of This: "The glowing lights of high-beams rested upon her as a sleek black Jaguar pulled up via the covered road towards the scenic overlook." The best methods of imagery always include action, people look at pictures for images, people read for action. Imagery should therefore be a device for action, so without all my fluff use more indirect imagery than direct imagery. Plot- I like strong plots. This didnt have one, but I can cope. I like how the narration fits in with all of this character bulding all through metaphor. It simple but I do belive that there is a right way and wrong way to do things. Here you did need more of that famous formula weve been though since elementry school- rising action, climax, falling action, resolution. By no means does this have to be your focus, but it does have to exist. Otherwise its just not a story. Language- Your diction is forced in some places. I have a list of words improperly used below, finding them and changing them us up to you- "Woodsy" "vigor"- not bad, just could be better "puffed" air cant puff unless your talking about a certain magic dragon "spunky" just a word that should be used unless you are trying to be corny in a "youve got spunk" type sentence "huffed" goes quite well with puffed... Your syntax can be screwy too in places I have some below. "When she reached the lookout, she skidded to a stop and pulled off her helmet, shaking out her matted hair and inhaling the brisk night air." a cumbersome sentence, just too much going on to be easy and fluid. " He had graduated top of his class at his Ivy League campus, had worked for several years with high end law firms and businesses before leaving the high end business elite for a sabbatical in Monterey." the two clauses just dont fit well togther, you need a conjunction buddy an and would fit well there. " He had graduated top of his class at his Ivy League campus, had worked for several years with high end law firms and businesses before leaving the high end business elite for a sabbatical in Monterey." I dont like this sentence. I just dont like it. I discussed it with Syrah and she agrees it needs a reformatting, I cant put my finger on it, but something has to be done. Characterisation- Kind of flat, but for such a short piece I should complain but I will. It seems to just good and evil to me. The bitch and the woman who plays by no rules but her own. I just cant see a woman who doesnt know her sons eye color, and doesnt really care about him, but yet goes to mourn him. I dont know I just dont like it. The main character though is fine, more could be done like I have yet to see a story where more couldnt be done. Final Thoughts- Youve wrote a well crafted story. I like the escapisim as Ive said like a million times. Your diction and syntax are where most of your work needs to be done. All I can say more is as you write more your characters and plots will become more complex, layers on top of layers, this doesnt have that yet, but it certainly provides a foundation for levels to be built upon it.
__________________
Why are you looking at this sig? You should probably be looking at the post.
Last edited by Maud; 08-10-2007 at 11:58 AM. |
|
|||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
Ok. Some of what I have to say might have already been addressed. Of what I scanned of the other comments I tried to omit those corrections... but here it is...
Quote:
Quote:
Here are some out of place words...... Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Over all this piece has a lot going for it. The beginning was a bit hard for me to get in to, but when the other car entered the piece you had me more interested. Perhaps a little more description that will give your other senses a tingle... you mentioned once wind... things like that. Temperature... etc. That or little flashes of her and David together while she's accelerating.... something to draw the audience in that bit more. I liked the voice.. it was really realistic to me. I think mostly this story needs a little more backstory, character developement (specifically of the main character and David's relationship would be ideal).. This is a piece that can easily be added to, making it longer and more multifaceted which will bring in more readers identifying with your writing. Keep up the good work, just don't shy away from taking your story to the next level.
__________________
![]() These crazy cats are covering the town in kitty litter!! You know we're the shit.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Ducati Recollect
Overall, I was impressed with the narrative voice in this. From a vocabulary and sentence structure point of view (and even from a topic one), I wouldn't consider this an "amateur" piece. The only problem I had with it is that it felt incomplete, like it was a piece of a larger story instead of something complete in and of itself.
Part of that is the characters. While I enjoyed the depth of characterization of the main character, I never felt enough of a connection to care. Also, the conflict felt disconnected as well - suddenly it showed up in a car after halfway through. I thought the descriptions were quite good, and the words flowed mostly smoothly. The use of numbers in relation to the motorcycle seemed a bit much. Mixing "kilos" and "miles per hour" in the same sentence threw me for a moment. And then having 999 ccs and 139 horsepower felt like another unit switch. Minor, but I did notice. Some additional word things: Quote:
Quote:
Those are minor. Again, overall, I was quite impressed! I'll have to read more of your pieces. And I would like to see more to this one, too. I think more depth to the characters and their interactions could make this even more enjoyable.
__________________
"We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams." ~ Arthur William Edgar O'Shaughnessy "Be bold and mighty forces will come to your aid." ~ Basil King |
|
||||
|
Instead of “What if,” you used “Perhaps,” and I thought that was brilliantly executed. Also I thought “Ducati” sounded familiar, but I wasn’t sure until I read the whole story. Again, well illustrated. The imagery was fantastic.
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|