| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
I think this might be the first thing I've ever read, as far as stories go, that didn't have any names in it at all. It was quite jarring and actually hurt the story. There are parts here and there where you used "her" or "him" when a name should have been used. The whole read I was waiting for a name, looking for one, but didn't find it. I think if you put some names to the characters, the story would flow a lot better.
The dialogue was a little blocky, it didn't really feel natural. I kept thinking that somone was reading from a script. Try to inflect a little more feeling into the dialogue. When you talk to someon, or overhear a conversation, pay clost attention to it, listen to how poeople talk and try to duplicate that in the voice and dialogue of your work. I didn't find too many punctuation errors and you appear to be very good at that or at least took the time to edit it. Nice job. There were some places that I just couldn't make heads or tails out of and could not figure out what you meant or what it had to do with the story. Maybe you could go through this one more time. Try to be as detached as you can be. Forget that you wrote the story and just read it, see what you come up with. I think that the biggest thing for me was the lack of introductions to the characters, and the lack of names. All of a sudden there is a guy, then there is a girl, he kisses her, she runs off, reporters come, then there is some kind of birthday party. While you have some pretty good descriptions, there are not a lot of them, it is a very stripped down and basic story. I think if you fleshed it out, added more details (use the senses: Sight, smell, touch, hearing...) and introduced your characters a bit more (and gave them names) this could be the start of a pretty decent story. Do not be afraid of too much description, it is a rare thing when you can over-describe a scene, situation, or characters. The more description, the more captivating your story will become. Keep pluggin' away at it, you will only get better and better.
__________________
Go vote on a challenge or more birds will DIE! Quote:
|
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
Hello Jimbalaya... Thank you for your comments and suggestions. I was actually waiting for someone to comment on this one.
You suggested that I put on names on the characters. Well, this story is about confusion and well, I'm sorry but I just can't go on with the names. But I think you would realize that I've mentioned a name. Lia. Yup, that's the girl the narrator loves. and it was her brother who talked to our writer here. Well, its only the explanation i've got coz i might spill details the readers should realize... I've never even mentioned who really is the narrator. Yes, all we know is that the narrator is a writer. And I think that is enough in this story. It has continuation though I forgot to mention. Just check the next one to this and I think you will understand better. *smiles* You also mentioned reporters I've never written reporters on this one. I think you just misread this or misinterpreted. Well, try reading this again. And I think you will follow the flow of the story. My dialogue is really straight forward. I also feel that it was somewhat empty... I'll try to improve it. Thanks again for the comment Last edited by beverent; 27-05-2008 at 11:06 AM. |
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
Hi,
firstly let me commend you on a not unique, but for me, refreshign change of tack. I enjoyed this and was held throughout just by the style, it is what it is least to me and as it grew became more ethereal almost but real or your style certainly gave it added impotus. Touching and not overdone with the clutter which would ahve spoiled your intent maybe..I suk at this but I enjoyed it.
__________________
Did you know...points are up for grabs....just for entering... 250 - LIMERICK, CFPC, 55, EMWE, 1000 - TotM, 1000 WC 100 - VOTING IN A CONTEST POLL, YES, JUST VOTING! ![]() Comp/Challenges FFFC CFPC 1000-Word Challenge Limerick ToTM EMWE GQC |
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
thanks lubesh for your comment... haha thought i'd recieve some corrections but a praise (?) coming from you... im honored. well, yeah you got my point exactly. Giving too much would really spoil something in this story. well thanks again.
|
|
|||||
|
Will facing the truth be the solution or will it forever (hide) hidden behind a mask? (I think it should be ‘hide’ or some other word.)
On just a superficial look, the spacing bothers me. There’s too much in between the paragraphs. Unless this serves a purpose I strongly recommend changing it. Some constriction here… Quote:
Quote:
What about…… Quote:
What about throwing in to make more personal… Quote:
Is your main character looking up from the laptop? If so then… Describe his tone, then line of speech. I glanced up from the laptop? Just caught this, why would he care to look at your laptop? Again, combination… Quote:
Maybe some *** where you are starting, showing a new scene. You are being very repetitive where you could be straight to the point. (I am speaking about your ‘party scene/conversation.’) I think you mean…I don’t remember much of what happened after my little blunder on her birthday. (Just something more flowing.) An extremely interesting story. Almost anyone who has wanted to be loved or has been in love can relate to this situation. I think there remains some grammar and punctuation errors, but ask an actual editor about this. You were repeating, as I am being now, but I suppose it’s necessary for this write you have posted. I will give 3/5!
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
Here's my post, as promised.
First of all: Your writing is very good. I noticed no errors really, and I like your style. Also, your narration is very good, but your dialogue does need a little work. Just at some parts it doesn't seem so fluid or realistic. About you not using any names, although it does sometimes make reading it a little confusing or makes it look a little messy, it's part of your style and I don't think it absolutely has to change for this piece. A little background on the characters would be nice, but this story is just a sort of (I think I may actually coin a word for this,) fragmentort (I just made that up). Its a story that describes a mood, theme, or idea, without having a basic storyline or characters (if there is an actual term for this type of writing someone let me know), which is perfectly fine. So there was my review, and I hope you'll return the favor.
__________________
According to Dante's Divine Comedy, Flatterers are condemned to the Eigth Circle of Hell. Ah crap. |
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
thank you rena for your suggestions and corrections. I am really pleased that this story interests you. You've got few corrections that I think are detailed and would help me a lot improve in this one and even in my writing. Thank you
|
|
||||
|
Re: Something I Can't Tell
well dan, i am glad you liked the story and my style of writing. hehehe. i'm quite flustered right now. hahaha
you're right in assuming that this story is just a fragment of something bigger. i'm thinking of making other stories related to this. i dunno if that'll work though. you've also mentioned about the dialogues... hmmm... i'm thinking about it now. well thanks again for this review and i would gladly make reviews for your works , just PM me whenever you got something/ |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|