| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools |
Rating:
|
Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Alright, right after the whole "You" part...slowly I think you rush it. And its a little cliche. Its done lots and lots of time, childhood friends fall in love, kind of work on it a bit. Put it through the thinking process a little bit longer. Wow, that was random, a little boy in the compartment? Quote:
Quote:
Oh Masa, I don't even know where to start with this ending. And this was by far one of my favorite pieces by you. 1. The little boy randomally wakes up and buys a pencil? That's all his significance is? 2. "Yes, I think so" Wow, so unbelievably romantic... 3. Falls asleep....?! They confess their love for one another then he decides to take...a nap. Really Masa, you should've went a different way. Last edited by LullabyHearts; 19-08-2007 at 11:18 PM. |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
Third-years is Japanese Highschool's last year, about to head to college. The pair were afraid that they would be forced to seperate when they go to college.
Now for the ending: 1. That little boy is a determent, it's to make you wander off and ponder his significance, only to realize that the little boy is simply a symbol of youth and its blindness to the warm fuzzy moments taking place in the story. 2. And this pair is lax, I explained that somewhere in there. 3. I would have done the same, trains make you so sleepy... and I wanted the last thing for him to see was his companions smiling in the end. Just like back in his flashbacks. --- Haruna, I'd like to really thank you for reading this and critiquing it, I'm very grateful that you would have put your time to this task.
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
Oh. I think you should explain the third-year thing, personally.
and with the little boy, I did take notice that his symbolism was youth. I'm just not sure you put it across the best way. Once again, personally. And with the sleepy, okay I understand that with the sleepy thing...although...I don't know. As a romantic piece, its not completely there. And yes, of course. I needed something to read, it was first on the list in the romance section. I was happy to read it. |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
Apart from the few things already pointed out, I say this piece is rather nice.
Its romantic almost, but not cheesey at all (at least, I don't think it is!). Apart from that, it would have been nice to have some names, but leaving them nameless might do the trick, since I could give those two people their own names, and leaves it to my imagination. Maybe I'm just being love-struck at the moment! For drama though, I'm all for a few more descriptions of the landscapes they are passing. Good piece though! Ferris |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
I didn't even realize they were nameless, how lame of me. I kind of liked how they were nameless. Because the piece is about the confession of love...not really the history of their love.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
This was great. I personally don't think anything needs to be changed. You captured the mood perfectly and I loved the nonchalant way in which the characters declared their love for each other. It was perfect, they knew it all the time. I also thought the extra little boy was a nice touch, especially in relation to the pencils.
Now that I've said all that, I'd just like to add :throw up: :throw up:
__________________
In the 1990s, the number of fictional stories depicting nuclear holocaust dropped off. Everyone thought things would be ok. Now its 2013 and I'm writing a story about a nuclear holocaust. This one is true. --From the Journal of Lexica Jones
|
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
Hehehehe, now you know why romance is not one of my specialities...
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
No Masa, I disagree. It may not come off as hardcore romance, but I really think this is your best piece. True, you have some loose ends, I would perfer you to fix (but its up to you) but this is pretty amazing.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
On the contrary Haruna, I was on a train such as this when I wrote this, and I was very sleepy, that may tell you why there is such a relaxed sort of feeling to the entire thing.
Oh, I may as well tell you, this is Japan, and I was a little thoughtless about the third-year thing. I'm a first year now, and so I was wondering whether I should go to Japan for schooling, then I wondered what would happen to my friends there (Japanese Highschools are unlike American, most you must take entrance exams just in order to enter the highschool, better your grade, better school, I lucked out with an A school near Shogawa-michi, but the people there are cruel...) Does that help you understand any better? Oh, and my introduction has been fixed to be a bit more pleasant in terms of my poetic foolishness. P.S - I own a little black journal, the same in which I wrote this story in. And pencils in the trolley are expensive.
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... Last edited by Masa; 20-08-2007 at 11:50 PM. |
|
|||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
I just wanted to say that i liked this story though i was confused at first but i read it over again and loved it...
|
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
Why thank you unregistered! I greatly appreciate such a wondrous comment!
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... |
|
|||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
I was hooked from the beginning. Normally I go through works thinking "Where's the mistakes I can fix" but after:
Quote:
|
|
||||
|
Applauses so many applauses.
My only inquiry is did you intend “thought” here? He was about to continue sketching, but her voice interrupted his train of through. “What are you drawing, anyway?” He was about to continue sketching, but her voice interrupted his train of thought. “What are you drawing, anyway?”
__________________
Right, I'll keep to the present but just take a glance at the past. Damn, is this poetry?
![]() |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
The plot's sort of cliche. But meh today, everything's cliche right?
|
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
WorldWarCheese: Thanks for your compliments, description is the heart of a story, although I do tend to go overboard and describe the obvious. And no worries of your college buddies, if anyone knew writing Romance was a hobby of mine, my companions wouldn't allow it to be forgotten either.
bombman: Sorry, but storiesmania is where I write, although 2ch I have heard is as pleasant as always. ごめん、2ch あまり つかいません。 My romaji is, I'm afraid, very rusty. RENA: Yes Rena, I will fix that right away, I am grateful I have people with such sharp eyes looking over my things. PaperAnchor: Is not love cliche? Haha, thanks.
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... |
|
||||
|
Re: Train Ride Home
ゴメンね。僕、日本語は上手く読めないんだよ。もし良かったら、 英語で書いてくれないかな?もしかしたら、日本語の翻訳ソフトを 使ってるの?文章がちょっと読み難いんだよね。^^ ;
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... |