| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
this story needs a lot of work. for one, the comma splices were giving me a headache just removing them. most of the times, using a period is just fine.
the beginning was somewhat odd. i thought the story was going to be about mr. gray, and then suddenly, it's clio and hunter. you might want to revise that. you are quite draggy with Hunter's history. and you showed us way too much at this stage of the story. one of the things that keeps a reader in a story is mystery. you might want to give us a hint now and then about Chloe. make Hunter think about the kiss with Chloe, stop, then give us more about Hunter and Clio. insert them in bits. i also thought that Clio's behaviour wasnt much in line. she cracked a grin, then she was smiling uneasily. next thing we know, she was laughing cutely. it's almost as if she's a schizo. with characters, their current mood has to be in sync, unless there is something happening that changes that. and go easy on ID tags! unless your versace jacket is meant to show how rich Hunter might be, otherwise, dump it! and what's with the Life's Guide to Biology book? a book is a book, it doesnt matter what unless it lends a hand to the story. finally, do less telling and more showing; remove the redundant. example: Quote:
__________________
"I like to write in the night, when everyone is asleep and I can hear the silence reverberating like an audio feedback. That is because I need the quiet to get into myself and open the doors to the noise in my head." - Me Internet home-based business for the clueless. Social. Savvy. Suave - Be a social artist. |
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
Very nice. A personal preference for me is that I'm not all that keen on explicitly stated slang IE "Ya" instead of "You." It's a constant reminder that I'm actually reading something rather than being there.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
Your story was nice but it did drag a bit. We got to know about Hunter and Chloe but we didn't really see much of Hunter and Clio. There's a slight continuity issue, I'm probably being unreasonable as they could be a plausible explanation but you mention a £150 jacket when they are in America, shouldn't it be $150. You mentioned New York not London. I'm being overly critical but small stuff tends to bug me. Hope you finish your story soon. A few bugs to iron out but it seems promising.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
I overall enjoyed the story but i agree with the poster above with the slang comment. To me it just doesn't fit right in certain stories. What I did like was the short description of Chloe and the first time they expressed their love for each other. I do think that we received a little too much backstory though. But I enjoyed reading it, and I am looking forward to more of it.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
awesome job. i thought all the vivid desriptions and elaborations brought the story together pretty well. it sounds almost like a classic "love/breakup" story. the only thing u should prolly change is some of the punctuation like the commas and stuff. Other than that, u have a very intersting story.
__________________
"I hate the way you say my name like it's something secret. My pen is the barrel of the gun. Remind me which side you should be on...."- Fall Out Boy |
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
the story was good but it was a little long.
__________________
Not everything makes sense , except to those who have lived it |
|
|||
|
Re: Broken
Some parts of this story were good, others wern't very accurate and awkward. For example: the main charectors relationships changed around a lot, there were a lot of british elements to this story set in America, and there was a little too much detail at some parts.
Things like that |
|
|||
|
The story looks like from a real experience though at times it dragged a bit with detailed expalnation! Good work! Keep it up. Waiting for few more stories from this author.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Broken
Hmmm. Lots of promise, here but somewhat incomplete. When I finished it, I went, "...and?" Where's the rest of it? You introduce Clio, she walks offstage, and we don't see her again. You have the makings of a good one; you just need to go back and finish it.
__________________
...a sucker for beautiful, soulful eyes
|
|
|||
|
Re: Broken
I actually really disagree with the last comment you got.
And I think that person made himself seem a little stupid, critisizing you so harshly but sounding pretty un-educated himself. *Shrug.* Just my opinion. Anyway. Forgetting him. About your story. I think it was a great start, actually. The plot seems pretty cute, and I love the little heartbreaker and the flashback to his last girlfriend. That was a great addition to the first part. But there are a few things that could be better if you edited a little more. I think your vocabulary is good, and your wording, but watch where you put commas; it can make it different for the reader. I know, but it hards, because you wrote it, so when you edit it, you know exactly what you mean. But sometimes it just doesn't sound right for someone reading it for the first time. Also, watch run on sentences. It's usually pretty good to have lots of shorter sentences than a few long, confusing run-on sentences. And I think it was a little weird to end with the flashback. Maybe you could have written a little more - he flashes back to the present and smiles because he thinks the new girl seems different than Chloe? Not that you have to use that plot, but just a little to get us out of dreamland? I just think that could help :] But anyway. I really did enjoy reading this. With a few minor changes, I think it could definitely be golden :] I'm Taylor, by the way. I'm new here, but I'm a member at a different writing website. I decided to check out some stories here to see if they're as good as my other site. It seems, this being the first I've read, I'll find some talent. Good work, and I hope you keep writing and improving - you're a good writer! If you write more to this, you can give me a shout out - a message - and I'll come back and read it. :] [Sorry about the critisizm. I can find things to improve in the best writings in the world -Tay |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| None |
| Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|