| Notices |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
| Sponsored Links |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Quote:
Ok mate. Going to be completely honest with you. Because judging by your posts you respect honesty. There are elements of this story I enjoyed and other not so much. First style. Now grammatically this was in shambles. Did you read through it before posting? You changes tense every couple of minutes and there was verb confusion, apostrophe misuse, excess of commas and incorrect capitalization in your dialogue. But then again what am I here fore. Also your writing style also can be a bit imprecise at times, and run on sentences and whatnot don't help your flow. Now the story. Interesting idea, you're right, the high-school love story is so cliched it's not funny. But this wasn't bad. The whole 'puddle duck' thing could've turned out nauseatingly dull but you used it subtly so it didn't induce vomit. Quite sweet actually. I don't see the significance the burglar, I have my theories, but I guess I have to wait for the next chapter aye? Well you hooked me in. Keep writing, you've definitely got skill, just a style that could d sue some refining. Nice job.
__________________
I like boys with strong convictions and convicts with perfect diction, Underdogs with good intentions Amputees with stamp collections -So Nice, So Smart |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Grammar wise this piece sucks. And no I didn't look over it before I posted it...I will admit that. I wrote this last year. My writing style has changed a lot. So I'm looking for some feedback and then I'm going to fix it up.
Yeah the idea is seriously sweet I think. And the burglar won't really show up again for a little bit longer. Its basically a foreshadow, teaser. Glad you didn't think the puddle duck wasn't sickening. So yes the grammar. I'm ashamed...Oh and the dialogue is horrid. Eww its so bad. By the way: Thanks for finally posting a story of mine. I'm so excited. |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Haha. Thanks mate. Don't mind me...I'm usually a lot nicer. But it's late and my eyes are starting to get blurry. Looking forward to seeing your newer pieces mate and the next chapter.
__________________
I like boys with strong convictions and convicts with perfect diction, Underdogs with good intentions Amputees with stamp collections -So Nice, So Smart |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Next chapter...hmmm might be a little longer. I've been having a hard time with it...for well...a year...
|
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
It'd decent, but
OH HERE IT IS! THE WORST THING MASA CAN SAY!!! It feels really broken. Like you put an idea down just to write it, then you sort of break up a little and shoot for another go... almost like a bad game of golf. However seeing that Masa is actually quite good at putting things together, I could understand it! It's a nice story, I DO LIKE IT!
__________________
You guys all know I'm a lazy reviewer, so please PLEASE PM me if you want a specific poem or story commented on! There's no pleasure in eeny-meany-mieny-moe-ing everything nowadays! Yare yare... |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Well, there was a flash back and a major foreshadow, and a slight reconcile...A lot goes on in this chapter
|
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Main recomendation? I recommend trying page breaks, keeping everything in one tense - preferrably past tense. One more recommendation: try to rewrite it as I don't think you've touched it for awhile, correct?
Well, good job and good luck! I wish there was a thumbs up I could use but... |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Oh when I rewrite this. Woah. It'll be so much better. Like crazy.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
i wasn't really paying that much attention to the grammar, but there were a couple of parts that i had to reread, i guess i've been roleplaying too much to really notice the grammar mistakes like i should. . . i really can't wait for more. . . plz keep it coming. . .
Kat
__________________
If YOU don't talk to your CAT about catnip, who will? |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Like I've said there won't be anything coming for a couple years. My characters are too old for me. I haven't experienced everything they have.
|
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
ohh thats too bad. . . keep me posted anyway though. . . and your warning still won't keep me from checking every week. . .
Kat
__________________
If YOU don't talk to your CAT about catnip, who will? |
|
||||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
Well I have other pieces. And currently brainstorming a new idea out.
So any suggestions to make this chapter better? |
|
|||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
The change in tenses made me sort of trip out for a second. (But I guess that's already been stated by others...) Other than that, I think it's pretty good. I really like the idea behind it and you have interesting characters. I can't wait to see the next chapter! (Whenever that would be...)
|
|
|||
|
Re: Puddle Ducks: Chapter 1
I liked it. The whole "Puddle Ducks" thing is pretty cool. I'd have never thought of something like that.
Nice job |